Long before October of 1929, the idea of organized fire protection in Brighton was already beginning to take shape. At the time, much of the area consisted of open fields, farms, and a small number of homes located between Ellicott Creek and the New York Barge Canal. Establishing what would become
Brighton Volunteer Fire Company #5
required countless meetings, petitions, careful planning, and discussions with residents and local officials.
At the center of much of this effort was
Walter M. Kenney,
whose persistence and dedication helped move the organization forward. The early meetings that helped shape Brighton’s future were held in a small one-room schoolhouse, the building that later became the Brighton Library. Those meetings brought together farmers, homeowners, and newly arrived residents to discuss the importance of organized volunteer fire protection. For some, it was their first real experience with the volunteer fire service. One future founding commissioner even recalled that as a boy he had once viewed volunteer firefighters with skepticism, only to later proudly become part of the very organization he had once questioned.
Kenney prepared much of the legal paperwork and petitions necessary for the effort, and when the proposal was eventually brought to a vote,
not a single dissenting vote was cast.
Not every resident supported joining the new fire protection area. Residents of Ellicott Creek Estates chose not to participate, leaving that area outside the original boundary. Despite this, Brighton firefighters responded there for a time when requested by Town Police, often without compensation, until it was eventually ruled that the company could no longer provide protection to the area.
By the spring of 1930, the organization legally existed but had almost nothing:
no fire hall, no fire trucks, little equipment, and very little money.
To help establish the new operation,
$30,000 in bonds
were issued and purchased by investors as far away as New York City. The funds helped finance the first fire hall and firefighting equipment.
The first board included
W. Stephen Murdock
as chairman, along with Archie Nadon, Alvin Love, John Faulahaber, and Charles H. Murphy. Albert J. Taylor served as secretary and treasurer. Walter Kenney continued to play an important role behind the scenes, often presenting ideas that commissioners could formally act upon.
Plans for the first fire hall originally called for a simple wooden structure and a used fire truck, but after visiting neighboring departments, the commissioners decided that a more permanent building would better serve future generations. Plans were drawn for a brick fire hall with heating and plumbing. Even seemingly small decisions were carefully debated, including whether to install a dumbwaiter to carry food and drinks from the kitchen to the upstairs hall. The dumbwaiter was ultimately rejected, and a full basement was chosen instead. These early choices helped shape a fire hall intended to serve the company and community for generations.
Construction took place during the difficult years of the Great Depression. A local contractor,
George F. Wallace,
offered to build the fire hall at cost plus only $1,000 and passed material discounts along to the organization, saving thousands of dollars. Firefighters themselves also helped with construction whenever possible, and many were grateful for the opportunity to work on the building that would become their firehouse during a time when jobs were scarce.
Brighton eventually purchased its first fire truck, a
Mack,
which quickly became a source of pride for the commissioners and firefighters. Although other departments favored American-LaFrance equipment, Brighton stood firmly behind its choice, and the Mack became a symbol of the determination of the early members. Even long after it became outdated, original members continued to speak of it with pride.
Walter Kenney never served for long as president, chief, or officer of the company, but his influence could be found in many of the major decisions made during Brighton’s early years. His dedication, persistence, and vision helped transform a rural collection of farms and homes into a community protected by an organized volunteer fire company.
From those humble beginnings, Brighton Volunteer Fire Company #5 grew into a proud organization serving the Town of Tonawanda. Through financial struggles, legal challenges, the Great Depression, and generations of change, the dedication of its early members created a legacy that continues today in every firefighter who answers the call and every resident who depends on
Brighton Volunteer Fire Company #5
to stand ready to serve.

